Phylloxera and ungrafted vines: a tiny insect, a European crisis and two ways of growing vines
A tiny insect, a European crisis and two ways of growing vines

Phylloxera galls on a vine leaf, Pennsylvania — Beatriz Moisset, Wikimedia Commons · Original photograph · CC BY-SA 4.0
The insect that changed the vineyard
In the 19th century, exchanges of plants between North America and Europe transported an almost invisible enemy: phylloxera, Daktulosphaira vitifoliae. This small sap-feeding insect, related to aphids, caused a major winegrowing crisis. The first damage was reported in the Gard in 1863; in 1868, botanist Jules Émile Planchon helped identify the culprit. Vines declined, harvests disappeared and entire regions had to rebuild their vineyards.
Why the roots were threatened
Phylloxera can take several forms during its life cycle. The root-feeding form is particularly destructive to the European vine, Vitis vinifera: its feeding causes deformities and wounds that compromise root function. Galls visible on some leaves correspond to another form of the insect; they alone do not convey the severity of underground attacks. Phylloxera is still present today. Viticulture learned to protect the roots rather than eliminate the pest permanently.
The paradox of the rescue
The lasting solution came from America, the continent from which the insect had arrived. During their coexistence with it, American vine species developed better tolerance of root attacks. Winegrowers therefore graft their European varieties onto rootstocks derived from these species. The upper part retains the chosen variety and produces its grapes; the lower part provides the roots. A grafted Cabernet Sauvignon remains a Cabernet Sauvignon: it does not become a mixture of two varieties in the glass. The rootstock nevertheless matters greatly for adaptation to soil, drought and plant vigour.
What does ‘ungrafted’ mean?
An ungrafted vine grows on its own roots, without a rootstock. This was the usual situation for European vines before the crisis. Some plots survived or can still be grown this way in conditions unfavourable to the pest, notably certain very sandy soils. Ungrafted does not automatically mean very old: a recent plant can also be ungrafted. Conversely, an old vine can be grafted. Age, soil, vine management and winemaking all shape a wine’s expression.
Etna and Nerello Mascalese
On Etna, some old plots of Nerello Mascalese have retained their own roots. At Cavanera Etnea, Firriato notably preserves an old vineyard whose heritage value has been documented through botanical and genetic analyses. These survivors fascinate us: they connect today’s landscape to viticulture before the crisis. Their preservation reflects the particular conditions of those plots. At La Corte Segreta, this history accompanies our curiosity about Italian grapes and terroirs.

Ungrafted and grafted vines — an explanatory diagram by La Corte Segreta, not to scale.
Nerello Mascalese: freshness and depth on Etna’s slopes →
Firriato: one Sicily, several landscapes in the glass →
Nebbiolo: the long passage of time in Piedmont and the Alps →